Why we shouldn’t set our clocks back

The issue of changing our clocks back to the GMT+5 1/2 time has been one of much discussion and contempt over the last few weeks. In the mid 1990’s Sri Lanka set its clocks forward by a half hour (corresponding to a GMT+6 time zone) on the directive of then President CBK, with one’ve the main reasons being the severe energy crisis faced by the nation at the time. It was hoped that the additional half hour of daylight in the evenings would reduce electricity consumption significantly, thereby somewhat easing the burden faced by the national grid. While the premier insists that the time change has not resulted in much of a power saving and the benefits of the earlier time are greater, and tech guru Arthur C. Clarke vehemently opposing the taking back of the clocks, it has been decided that from the 14th of April our clocks will indeed be pushed back by an hour. It will correspond to the time of the astrological ‘litha’ as well as the standard time observed in the Tiger controlled areas of the North and East. All this is very sweet and convenient, but how much consideration has the premier put into this in terms of the impact it has on the economy?

Sri Lanka is very much integrated in the global business arena. Whether it’s shipping and air freight or an international BPO centre, the time change affects business activity in a seemingly infinite number of ways.

Banks and other financial institutions that run their own Treasury and Trading departments will have to change their clocks, readjust their trading times, re-evaluate the global market synchronisation strategies and do a bit of an overhaul to their systems. These treasuries are where all the biggest and most lucrative FOREX trading takes place. Being in sync with different time zones is crucial to them, and a change such as this, does little help.

Other sectors affected by the times change would be airlines and tourism. Airlines will be compelled to revise their entire flight reschedule, carry out revisions with international air traffic control, and revise there systems to suit the new time of the country. Many airlines have already expressed their disappointment that the time change is being enacted without much consultation with affected parties like themselves.

Another very significant change would be seen in the computer systems sector, where all the new computers running MS Windows have been programmed with Sri Lanka being GMT+6 in their internal clocks. The revision of this will be a costly and cumbersome effort, no doubt.

However, the president stands by his argument that the energy saved by the time change has not been significant enough to warrant the continuation of this time. Right. So assume we didn’t save more than a couple of thousand mega watt hours per month. But we SAVED a couple of thousand mega watt hours a month! – a massive saving for a country neck-deep in a severe power shortage and sky-rocketing energy prices! Those of you in industry will know how burdening this crisis has come to be. Over the last decade, this issue of high energy prices and the national grid being choked to capacity has resulted in a rise in cost of production for factories, adversely affected competitiveness of exporting industries, and severely hindered foreign investment prospects. With Norochcholai still in development and Dendro power still in its infancy, the existing hydro and diesel power plants can barely cope with the national energy demand. Now is certainly not the time to throttle our national grid with an additional hour of power guzzling every evening, everyday.

Again, he reiterates that the move by CBK at the time may have seemed the logical step to conserve energy, but according to him, it caused more inconvenience than did good. This next argument is not exactly an economic one, and hence I will not dwell on it in detail. The president claims that much inconvenience is caused to school children by the current time. They are required to wake up much earlier, and go to school while it is still dark outside. But wouldn’t it be an even bigger hassle to get your children adjusted to yet another new time? How long do you think it’ll take? Also consider the fact that the lost daylight in the morning is well compensated for by the fact that school’s now begin at 8am and not at the previous time of 7.30am.
This also applies to the labour force of the country, especially in highly commercialised areas. The inconvenience caused to them by having to completely revamp their daily travel and living timings has been ignored.

The children-having-to-wake-up-early argument seems the only one being voiced by the president and others advocating this change. Personal opinion: that argument is far too trivial to be the basis of such a dramatic decision. Carry out a small poll, a referendum maybe. See what the general public actually feel about it. Do they agree with your conception that the time should be pushed back just to suit this purpose? Surely, there must be some economic reasoning behind it, considering the economic impacts the change would have? Even if it is the most convincing argument to the general public, isn’t it a minor trade-off to have to make? Considering how much more is actually at stake? Altering and re-altering major national features of a country which is quite integrated in the global economy is not a very prudent move. In our quest to become a more investor-friendly, stable and business-conducive economy, this time change will not go down as one’ve our smartest moves.

About these ads

5 thoughts on “Why we shouldn’t set our clocks back

  1. If the problem is with school hours, then simply adjust the school times, no need to change the clock.

    The problem is El Presidente Mustachio is a simple man from the village. Some idiot soothsayer probably put it into his head that karma will improve if the clock is changed.

    It tells you something of the pig headedness and stupidy of the man in charge, who Sittingnut has appropriately dubbed The Buffalo.

  2. Well said. Don’t even want to think about the thought procedure(or lack thereof) that went into making this decision. Like you said, it might very well have been on the oh-so-mighty advice of an astrologer that MR frequents. I only hope it’s not the same chap that CBK visits.
    PS – have a look at Prof. Harsha De Silva’s article in this morning’s Daily FT. He has an interesting take on the matter too.

  3. ‘Lets screw up the whole country so that school kids have an extra hour of sleep’

    oh pls 8-)

    What kinda insanity is that? Like u said it is far too trivial, and what good is there gonna come out of it anyway?School kida for the past 7 or 8 years went to school at that time, and it was alright with them…personally, like u said, it is a more ego-battle/non economic reason that anything remotely economic related…

    And pls pls DO NOT suggest another poll/referendum!! I know it is democracy but dont u think our country has enough of them…for a country sunk in many a different situation as well as an economic crisis and a rather unstable peace process..we waste enough money with polls/referendums/elections…

  4. the school argument is total crap.

    because when the clock was +5.30 GMT the schools started at 7.30 and finished at 1.30, then parents screamed abt the dark issue and they changed it to 8.00 to 2.00, so really the ppl have been going to skool at the same time not only for the last 8 years but for like ever! this is just extra half an hours sleep…

    ya sure, it was dark some times of the year.. bt who da hel cares? i didnt.. and i travlled like 25 kms to skool everyday

    stupid moron mahinda.. unfortunately this fact hasnt been brought up much even in the discussion..

  5. Pingback: Global Voices Online » Blog Archive » Sri Lanka: Setting back the clock

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s